Three Reasons to Insure with Butterfield Insurance.


Annual Review

At Butterfield Insurance, we call every client, large or small to review their policies at least once a year.  We do this to confirm that we are continually providing the proper coverages & to verify that each insured is receiving the best value available.


Claims Assistance

We actively stay involved in all of our clients' claims.  In fact, we advise our clients to call us first whenever possible.  We do this to verify that they receive exactly what is due to them at the time of a claim. Not all savings come on the initial price, but many savings are realized with proper coverages and payments made during the claims process.



At Butterfield Insurance, it is important for us to know that our clients understand the coverages that they are paying for.  Between the in-depth detail of the initial meeting, to the consistent follow-ups, we strive to make sure our clients understand how they are protected and all of the insurance options available to them.

What Our Clients Say

  • I've never had better customer service. For business or personal.

    - Karolyn Eversole  -

  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4

Proudly serving the insurance needs of Lima, Ohio and surrounding areas since 1942

Welcome to the home of Mel Butterfield & Son Insurance Agency, Inc. We have been serving Lima, Ohio and the surrounding areas since 1942.  Beginning with Mel Butterfield's vision, the family-owned independent agency has provided client oriented service for over 70 years.  We are proud to have family from both the third and fourth generations as current members of the agency.  Our entire staff's experience exceeds 95 years in the insurance industry, EXCLUSIVELY with the Butterfield Agency.

  • All
  • Auto
  • Business
  • Home
  • Life
  • Default
  • Title
  • Date
  • Random
  • Whether it is protecting yourself from others, protecting others from you, or protecting your vehicles, it is important to discuss the proper coverages with your local independent agent.
    Read More
    • Auto
  • From your home, to your belongings, to your personal liability, all of these are major concerns that should be discussed in great detail with a qualified insurance professional.
    Read More
    • Home
  • If you own your own business, it is typically your biggest asset. It is important that you properly protect that business so that it can flourish long into the future.
    Read More
    • Business
  • Should something happen to you, being able to provide for your family is the greatest gift that you can leave them. Let us help you develop a strategy that meets all of your needs.
    Read More
    • Life