Trusted Insurance in Lima, Ohio Since 1942
Your Family-Owned Insurance Agency
For over 80 years, we’ve helped families and businesses protect what matters most. Our family-owned agency, now in its third and fourth generations, is dedicated to providing personalized, client-focused insurance solutions.
Auto Insurance
Whether it is protecting yourself from others, protecting others from you, or protecting your vehicles, it is important to discuss the proper coverages with your local independent agent.
Home Insurance
From your home, to your belongings, to your personal liability, all of these are major concerns that should be discussed in great detail with a qualified insurance professional.
Small Business
If you own your own business, it is typically your biggest asset. It is important that you properly protect that business so that it can flourish long into the future.
Life Insurance
Should something happen to you, being able to provide for your family is the greatest gift that you can leave them. Let us help you develop a strategy that meets all of your needs.
Discover How Butterfield Insurance Puts You First
Benefits You Can Trust
Annual Review
Our dedicated team reviews your policies annually to ensure you’re always getting the best coverage and value.
Claims Assistance
We stand by you during claims, providing support and guidance to ensure you get what you deserve quickly and efficiently.
Education
We prioritize your understanding, offering detailed insights into your coverage options so you can make informed decisions.
What Our Clients Say
"I've never had better customer service. For business or personal."